The Dismantling of Democracy: A Grim Projection of American Fascism Under Trump
[Graphic: “Trump Gets Immunity“, Paresh Nath, U.T. Independent, India. (Not public domain, fee paid)]
By: Henry A. Giroux
Source: Counterpunch
“…argues that the executive branch of government, held in the hands of the President, has the sole right to ignore all laws (including the Constitution and international agreements), and without oversight by Congress, or checks by the Supreme Court. In short, the President is above the law and has all the authority of government, and the right to order without challenge all branches of government. This includes ordering the U.S. military into war without authorization by Congress. In short, the “unitary executive,” as vested in the person of the President, is a king, an emperor, or a dictator.”
While the immunity decision goes a long way toward providing a contemporary legal footing for the President as a Unitary Executive, the Court also arrogated to itself the power to decide what is and is not a presidential duty. This is placing a tremendous amount of power into the hands of the Supreme Court; however, it also gives tremendous room for arbitrary application. While they provided protection for Trump to determine that those who disagree with him can be incarcerated (or worse), it seems unlikely that they would allow Biden (for example) that same scope of authority. This placing of power in the hands of the court goes to other recent rulings, such as removing the power of governmental agency experts to implement and enforce policy in the Chevron decision. This ruling placed the determination of policy challenges firmly in the courts and not the experts and scientists, and hamstrings operations across the government.
We must also keep in mind Project 2025 which has been coordinated by the conservative think tank Heritage Foundation, it is largely written by those who served in the first Trump administration. Along with the laundry list of this 900-page handbook to the next Trump (or Republican President) is dismantling the Department of Education including public education, and programs such as Head Start and child hunger programs sponsored through the schools.It is the field manual for dismantling our current government and Constitution and implementing a fascist state. They have also rounded up over 20,000 Trump loyalists and trained them to take positions within the Trump administration. They have created a personnel database of loyalists to speedily put Trump’s people in position. (Carlos Lozada, NY Times 2/29/2024):
One of the “pillars” of Project 2025 is the creation of a personnel database — a sort of “right-wing LinkedIn,” The Times has reported, seeking to attract some 20,000 potential administration officials. “Mandate for Leadership” maintains that “empowering political appointees across the administration is crucial to a president’s success,” and virtually every chapter calls for additional appointees to wrest power from longtime career staff members in their respective departments.
So not only are “the guardrails of democracy blasted to dust” (Giroux), but the roads have all been paved to rapidly transform this nation into something unrecognizable to most of us. What is perhaps overlooked is the apocalyptic chaos that will almost certainly result from this “transition” to fascism under the rough hands of Donald J. Trump and his henchmen. Beware the 180 days they have planned to tear it all down.
Democracy and so much more are on the line in this election. Unfortunately, I fear that even if Donald Trump does not win the presidency, that does not mean that everything will return to a more forward-moving normalcy. The hornet’s nest that Trump, his ideologues like Bannon and the authors of Project 2025, and those who have embraced the Trump cult are not going to quietly let their dream die. The Republicans are not going to go back to sanity and supporting country over party. We have a long road back to recovering from the damage done, addressing the hate that has divided our nation, and moving forward to address the crises of our times and the rampant inequities we have yet to rise above.
Henry A. Giroux
The guardrails of democracy have been blasted into dust. The Supreme Court’s ruling on presidential immunity grants presidents carte blanche to commit crimes as long as they act within their “constitutional authority.” Welcome to gangster capitalism. Trump, the convicted felon, white nationalist, white supremacist, and aspiring dictator, can rest assured that his dream of unaccountable power will be realized if he is elected in November. With the legal cover to use his “official” power to commit endless crimes, the Supreme Court ruling effectively grants Trump the right, if elected, to become a domestic terrorist. Writing a dissent to the ruling, Justice Sotomayor rightly comments on its terrifying implications, calling it an extraordinary power grab and a glaring instance of maligned legality. She writes:
When [the President of the United States] uses his official powers in any way, under the majority’s reasoning, he now will be insulated from criminal prosecution. Orders the Navy’s Seal Team 6 to assassinate a political rival? Immune. Organizes a military coup to hold onto power? Immune. Takes a bribe in exchange for a pardon? Immune. Immune, immune, immune.
If and when he takes office, public services that operate, or are supposed to operate, in the name of truth, justice, and freedom will be largely disabled, just as the most crucial democratic rights will continue to be undermined. Young people will be written out of the script of democracy, staggering levels of inequality will increase mass immiseration, the economy will tumble into a massive recession, and blood will flow in the streets and abroad.
Critical ideas and thinking itself will be under siege, as well as any institution capable of producing them. Under Trump and his fascist sycophants, critical thought will disappear from public and higher education, social problems will be criminalized, the oppositional press will be shut down, women will lose control over their reproductive rights, the social state will morph into the punishing state, and the dark cloud of fascism will extinguish the dimming lights of democracy.
Even more tragically for democracy, Trump, if elected, will be able to institute a criminogenic system of law that can be used to assassinate his opponents, kill immigrants, imprison critics, and enact an American version of the Nazi Enabling Act, which allowed Hitler “to issue laws that laid the foundation for the complete Nazification of German society.” This corrupt Supreme Court, filled with bribe-takers, misogynists, and white supremacists, has just put democracy in a coffin. With the collapse of checks and balances that should provide a balance of power in the U.S., we will see a tsunami of barbarism and state violence in America, reminiscent of Fascist Italy, Chile under the ruthless Pinochet, and Nazi Germany. None of these predictions, given the rhetoric of revenge and violence Trump promises to enforce, should appear hypothetical.
Fascist politics, which is the endpoint of capitalism and a failed democracy, will no longer be a matter of historical analysis. First, it will emerge through a series of statutes outlined in Project 2025. As this project takes place, thousands of immigrants will be detained and put in prisons, dissidents will be rounded up and thrown in jail, and show trials will begin for Trump’s most hated enemies, including a range of judges, politicians, and outspoken critics.
Second, every aspect of social life will be militarized, leading to a culture of fear and state violence. Behind this will be the legitimizing force of a thoroughly corrupt Supreme Court majority and a repressive state apparatus, including the police and various elements of the armed forces. A hint of what might transpire is evident in Trump’s recent calls to jail “President Biden, Vice President Kamala Harris, Senators Mitch McConnell and Chuck Schumer, and former Vice President Mike Pence, among other high-profile politicians.”[1] Trump also called for a televised military tribunal to hold Liz Cheney responsible for treason. It will only be a matter of time before he and his sycophants, such as Stephen Miller, provide a list of alleged enemies to be potentially thrown out of planes, assassinated, or disappeared—tactics used by dictators like Pinochet in Chile. Given the Supreme Court’s ruling on presidential immunity, Trump’s deranged fantasies and penchant for revenge, violence, and unchecked authoritarianism can now unfold without any constraints, legally or politically. Welcome to a potential era of gulags, internment centers, and reign of state terrorism masquerading as entertainment and reality TV—broadcast daily on X. This fascist vision is clearly outlined in Project 2025, a 900-page American version of Mein Kampf.
How do we address the slow death of justice, the emergence of a culture of cruelty, the contempt for those perceived as different, and the complete erasure of any meaningful remnants of social and solidarity? It is hard not to feel the weight of profound loneliness in North America today. Shared values have been replaced not only by shared fears, but also by the collapse of civic literacy, and a value system in which intimacy and compassion, once central to public spaces, have mostly vanished. In the era of Trump, people turn into corpses, mere shells, devoted to the worship of money, violence, and greed. Critical thinking has become dangerous, with institutions once dedicated to it now besieged by white Christian nationalists and billionaire champions of ruthless capitalism.
As James Baldwin once noted, “One has to steal moments to think.” People are ensnared in a haze of historical and social amnesia that nurtures ignorance and mutual alienation. Social fragmentation has evolved into a kind of madness, trapping individuals who increasingly fall prey to the false sense of community offered by purveyors of hate and bigotry. The decay at the heart of capitalism reduces people to lifeless commodities who struggle to trust one another, mired in emotional poverty, a fear of solidarity, and a dread of expressing compassion and dignity. Neoliberalism’s corrosion thrives on manufactured enemies offering the disenchanted the illusion of feeling something, anything at all. This is not the country I grew up in because I no longer recognize it. I am not optimistic, but at the same time, while hope is diminished, it is not lost. Hopefully, mass resistance can persist even in the face of unimaginable odds. I hold onto Baldwin’s claim that “Even the emptiness of America can be overcome.”
Notes.
[1] Chris Cameron, “Trump Amplifies Calls to Jail Top Elected Officials, Invokes Military Tribunals,” New York Times (July 1, 2024).
A version of this essay originally appeared on LA Progressive.
Henry A. Giroux currently holds the McMaster University Chair for Scholarship in the Public Interest in the English and Cultural Studies Department and is the Paulo Freire Distinguished Scholar in Critical Pedagogy. His most recent books include The Terror of the Unforeseen (Los Angeles Review of Books, 2019), On Critical Pedagogy, 2nd edition (Bloomsbury, 2020); Race, Politics, and Pandemic Pedagogy: Education in a Time of Crisis (Bloomsbury 2021); Pedagogy of Resistance: Against Manufactured Ignorance (Bloomsbury 2022) and Insurrections: Education in the Age of Counter-revolutionary Politics (Bloomsbury 2023). Giroux is also a member of Truthout’s Board of Directors. His website is www.henryagiroux.com