CBP Facebook Group Displays Culture of Dehumanization and Violence
[Photo: DHS OIG report, 7/2019.]
By A.C. Thompson
Source: ProPublica
We should not be surprised at the Us-Them tenor, nor increasing dehumanization, particularly when policies are instituted that demand cruelty as political message. The structure itself increases the likelihood of drawing people into these agencies who may already have their own issues with race, immigrants, and expressing their power over others; the atmosphere created, tolerated, or even encouraged will inevitably push the boundaries of acceptable behavior. Once this starts to grow, and the situations begin to deteriorate, even those who might otherwise abhor such environments may find themselves doing and supporting things they would never have imagined themselves doing. This is in part due to norms sliding into barbarism, and cognitive dissonance. It is not uncommon when people are forced to do things that are repellent to them that they embrace a mind set that allows them to do what is demanded (or rewarded). In other words, we may change our attitudes and beliefs in order to reduce the very uncomfortable and internally threatening conflict in which we find ourselves. Such changes of attitude and belief may be part of what is referred to as “Stockholm Syndrome” where hostages identify with their captors, and most certainly in military situations where there is an explicit expectation of killing others – including civilians.
We have allowed the creation of a toxic environment, and we have stood back while a President who supports the “Alt-Right”, and a Republican Party that has deliberately structured itself along white supremacist grounds, has fanned the flames of “monster making” in regard to people from south of the border (and people of color within our own borders). While it is frightening that this hate and hate mongering is increasingly acceptable, as is demonstrated through the writings of the Facebook group below, but also in the reports from congress people of slurs and comments by detention center staff in front of their supervisors.
We are in dangerous waters, and the report below is but one very disturbing example of just how dangerous.
At what point do we start saying clear and loud “Not In Our Name”?
A.C. Thompson
The U.S. Customs and Border Protection agency has opened an investigation into vulgar and misogynistic social media posts made by members of a secret Facebook group for current and former Border Patrol agents.
On Monday, “U.S. Customs and Border Protection was made aware of disturbing social media activity hosted on a private Facebook group that may include a number of CBP employees,” said Matthew Klein, head of the agency’s internal affairs unit.
Klein said CBP “immediately informed” the investigators with the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General and initiated an inquiry. The office typically takes the first look at allegations of serious misconduct within the CBP.
The investigation comes after a ProPublica report exposing the secret three-year-old Facebook group, which is called “I’m 10-15” and has some 9,500 members. Group members posted offensive graphics, including a photo illustration of Democratic Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez being sexually assaulted by President Donald Trump; discussed plans to disrupt a congressional visit to a Border Patrol facility; and joked about the deaths of migrants.
Recent posts shared with ProPublica include a meme using graphic language to mock CNN anchor Anderson Cooper’s sexual orientation and a comment that referred to soccer star Megan Rapinoe as a man. A separate thread made fun of a video of a migrant man trying to carry a child through a rushing river in a plastic bag.
One poster wrote, “At least it’s already in a trash bag.”
Another wrote, “Sous-vide? Lol,” referring to a method of cooking in a bag.
Klein said CBP’s code of conduct bars employees from making hateful and abusive statements on social media.
The group’s posts were also condemned by Border Patrol Chief Carla Provost.
“These posts are completely inappropriate and contrary to the honor and integrity I see — and expect — from our agents day in and day out,” she said in a statement. “Any employees found to have violated our standards of conduct will be held accountable.”
The disclosure of the group’s existence and the nature of the posts raise a number of questions that remain unanswered. It’s apparent from some of the comments that agents were aware that the posts were inappropriate, and potentially actionable, for serving government employees. But it’s unclear whether CPB’s senior leadership was aware of the group or if any complaints had been made to the agency.
On Capitol Hill, the leader of a key oversight committee expressed outrage.
“This Facebook group is beyond sexist and racist — it is truly abhorrent and shameful, and there is no excuse for this depraved behavior,” said Bennie Thompson, a Mississippi Democrat who chairs the House Committee on Homeland Security, one of the committees with jurisdiction over CBP. “The agents found to be responsible for these vile comments should no longer have the privilege of representing the United States of America in uniform.”
The story generated widespread revulsion on social media, with more than a dozen members of Congress expressing horror and disgust at the posts. Some called for an investigation into the group
One of the targets of the offensive posts, Ocasio-Cortez, responded several times on Twitter.
This just broke: a secret Facebook group of 9,500 CBP officers discussed making a GoFundMe for officers to harm myself & Rep. Escobar during our visit to CBP facilities & mocked migrant deaths.
This isn’t about “a few bad eggs.” This is a violent culture. https://t.co/SkFwThHElx
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) July 1, 2019
The union representing Border Patrol employees, the National Border Patrol Council, issued a statement saying that the Facebook group is “not representative of our employees and does a great disservice to all Border Patrol agents, the overwhelming majority of whom perform their duties admirably.”
ProPublica’s reporting, the union said, “cited a handful of people who posted inappropriate content out of 9,500 members of the Facebook group, not all of whom are active active duty agents.”
But CBP insiders told ProPublica that the Facebook group has played host to offensive memes and degrading humor since it was launched in 2016.
“The problems with the 10-15 page have been going on for years,” said one current Border Patrol agent who asked to remain anonymous for fear of retribution. “No one has done anything about it.”
Inside the Secret Border Patrol Facebook Group Where Agents Joke About Migrant Deaths and Post Sexist MemesThe three-year-old group, which has roughly 9,500 members, shared derogatory comments about Latina lawmakers who plan to visit a controversial Texas detention facility on Monday, calling them “scum buckets” and “hoes.”
Heidi Beirich, the director of the Intelligence Project at the Southern Poverty Law Center, said she’d been pressing Facebook to pursue secret groups like 10-15 and hidden hate speech for years. Facebook, she said, “can use their AI or their people to identify these groups, and with the horrible language in there, they should have been finding these people.”
Facebook has not yet responded to questions from ProPublica.
Some members of the Facebook group predicted there would be trouble if the posts ever became public. “A bunch of people gonna regret comments they write on 10-15 if it shows up in court,” wrote one member in a post obtained by ProPublica.
“You understand this page is full of Agents, right?” replied another member, apparently suggesting that no one would expose the offensive comments of their fellow Border Patrol employees.
If you have any information about the Border Patrol you’d like to share, please email us at [email protected]. For more secure ways to send us information, please see instructions.
Engagement reporter Ariana Tobin contributed to this story.